Catastrophism, Natural Disasters and Cultural Change
s017
Convenors
John Grattan Institute of Earth Studies
Llandinam Building
University of Wales
Penglais
Aberystwyth
Dyfed SY23 3DB Wales
United Kingdom
Robin Torrence
Division of Anthropology
Australian Museum
6 College Street
Sydney NSW 2000
Australia
The aim of this session is to examine both the short and long-term consequences of extreme natural events on patterns of cultural change. Due to modern communication systems we are increasingly aware of the wide range and large number of severe climatic events that wreck havoc, destroy homes and livelihoods, and inflict high mortality in many parts of the world each year: e.g. storms, cyclones, floods, earthquakes, tsunamis, volcanoes. Natural disasters such as these must also have existed in the past and made their marks on both local and regional cultural histories. Recovery from extreme events is usually reasonably quick in modern societies because of worldwide links between communities, specialised programs of disaster assistance, etc. Nevertheless, long after the world press has moved on, such local catastrophes usually have profound long-term effects on the lives of the people involved and these can permeate and alter aspects of society as a whole. It therefore seems likely that natural disasters played an important role in human history, one that has been generally ignored by archaeology except on a case by case basis.
Archaeological theory about the pace and character of cultural change generally focuses on processes which are internally generated and which unfold slowly through time. Since environmental determinism has fallen out of favour, theories about social evolution pay very little attention to external, nonhuman factors nor to random factors. Little or no consideration has been given to the effects of one-off natural disasters. In contrast, a number of theoretical perspectives involving catastrophism, chaos, punctuated evolution, etc. provide a range of alternative views that focus on the effects of random events. One of the goals of the symposium is to assess the value of these theories for explaining the impacts of natural disasters on cultural change.
Through extended discussions following short presentations of case studies representing a very broad coverage in spatial, chronological and cultural terms, the participants will consider a range of general questions. How and in what ways do natural hazards affect human societies? Have natural disasters played an important role in human evolution? Do natural disasters have only short-term, limited effects or should they play an important role within general theories about cultural change and human evolution? How does the level of severity of disasters affect the nature of cultural response in various kinds of societies? What is the relationship between societal complexity and cultural responses to natural disasters? i.e. are simpler societies more resilient in the face of catastrophes than complex societies? In what ways do the short and long-term effects of natural disasters differ? Have societies adapted to hazardous environments and if so how?
By bringing together a broad range of case studies from around the world and by taking in the widest possible range of time periods and disciplines (e.g. physical anthropology, archaeology, oral history, and modern hazards research), we expect a varied and lively set of responses to these important questions from both the participants and the general audience.
papers:
Author 1 Author 2 Title
Allison The AD 79 eruption of MT Versuvius: Who has been affected?
Driessen The Eruption of the Santorini Volcano and Its Effects on Minoan Crete
Galipaud Catastrophism and Natural Disaster in Oceania
Grattan Volcanism, environmental forcing and the archaeological record. S017grt1
Lewis Johnson Natural disasters and cultural change in the Shumagin Islands
Machida Volcanic impact of explosive eruptions on natural environment and human societies in Japan, with specific reference to the great Kikai eruption
Manning Volcanoes and History: a significant relationship
Menotti Lake Constance transgressions as the cause of abandonment of the Arbon-Bleiche 2 Early Bronze Age lacustrine village S017mnt1
Neuman Narrating a disaster
Nur Haigan Armageddon’s Earthquakes
Nur The end of the Bronze Age by large earthquakes
Pavlides When the sky turns black and the rain turns to ash: cultural responses to volcanic disasters in the lowland tropical forests of Papua New Guinea
Rampino Ambrose Volcanic winter in the Garden of Eden: The Toba super-eruption and the Late Pleistocene human population crash
Shimoyama A case Study on the Development of the Disaster Archaeology Especially, on problems of adaptation against disaster
Stiros On the historical role of earthquakes and other natural phenomena in the eastern Mediterranean
Torrence Do disasters really matter? A long term view of volcanic eruptions and human responses in Papua New Guinea
Zeidler Isaacson Volcanic disasters and historical contingency: the prehistoric record of differential response to volcanic eruptions in Western Equador